Research progress of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy in metal reliability evaluation
YANG Qi1,2,3, YU Ziyu1,2,3, MA Weizhe1,2,3, LU Zhimin1,2,3 YAO Shunchun*1,2,3, LU Jidong1,2,3
1. School of Electric Power Engineering, South China University of Technology, Guangzhou 510641, China; 2. Guangdong Province Key Laboratory of Efficient and Clean Energy Utilization,Guangzhou 510641, China; 3. Guangdong Province Engineering Research Center of High Efficient and Low Pollution Conversion, Guangzhou 510640, China
Abstract：Critical metal components' service safety and reliability evaluation is the core guarantee of industrial safety products. Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) has been a rapidly developing atomic spectroscopy technique in recent years. It has attracted much attention in metal material reliability evaluation due to its unique advantages, such as no complicated sample pretreatment, simultaneous multi-element online analysis, and remote in-situ measurement. The article summarizes the methodological study of LIBS characterization of metal mechanical properties, including establishing a linear correlation between spectral properties (spectral line signal intensity and intensity ratio) and plasma temperature and metal mechanical property indexes. The mechanism of LIBS spectral characteristics to characterize metal aging state is sorted out, and the methods of LIBS to diagnose metal aging state, including establishing the correlation between spectral line signal intensity ratio and metal aging grade and using machine learning algorithms to improve the accuracy of prediction models, are introduced. The challenges and development status of the current development and application of portable LIBS devices are discussed, and the future research directions of LIBS in the field of metal mechanical properties and aging state characterization have been prospected.
杨淇, 喻子彧, 马维喆, 卢志民, 姚顺春, 陆继东. 激光诱导击穿光谱应用于金属可靠性评价的研究进展[J]. 冶金分析, 2023, 43(7): 1-10.
YANG Qi, YU Ziyu, MA Weizhe, LU Zhimin YAO Shunchun, LU Jidong. Research progress of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy in metal reliability evaluation. , 2023, 43(7): 1-10.
[1] Li X,Zhang Z,Li N,et al.Research of intergranular corrosion properties of heat affected zone for HR3C steel after aging treatment[J].IOP Conference Series:Materials Science and Engineering,2019,569:22-23. [2] 张帷,李超,张琪,等.金属材料力学性能试验试样验收方法[J].世界有色金属,2018(21):284-286. ZHANG Wei,LI Chao,ZHANG Qi,et al.Acceptance method for mechanical properties test specimens of metal materials[J].World Nonferrous Metals,2018(21):284-286. [3] 汪春.金属材料力学性能测试中存在的不确定度分析[J].化工管理,2023(3):36-38. WANG Chun.Uncertainty analysis in the mechanical properties of metal materials[J].Chemical Management,2023(3):36-38. [4] 冯柳,彭庆梁.扫描电镜在金属材料检测中的应用[J].世界有色金属,2020(16):208-209. FENG Liu,PENG Qingliang.Application of scanning electron microscope in metal material detection[J].World Nonferrous Metals,2020(16):208-209. [5] 朱果逸.痕量重金属电化学检测综述[J].现代科学仪器,2013(4):21-29. ZHU Guoyi.Review of electrochemical detection methods on trace heavy metals[J].Modern Scientific Instruments,2013(4):21-29. [6] 邱作元,周军委,管文华.特种设备常用无损检测方法综述[J].广东化工,2018,45(8):161-162. QIU Zuoyuan,ZHOU Junwei,GUAN Wenhua.A review of nondestructive testing methods used in special equipment[J].Guangdong Chemical Industry,2018,45(8):161-162. [7] 孙海龙,秦烨.钢棒材的超声波检测方法[J].哈尔滨轴承,2016,37(4):38-41. SUN Hailong,QIN Ye.Ultrasonic detection method of steel rod[J].Journal of Harbin Bearing,2016,37(4):38-41. [8] 邹明,陈晓.超声波检测技术研究进展[J].世界科技研究与发展,2010,32(2):198-199. ZOU Ming,CHEN Xiao.Progress in ultrasonic testing technology[J].World Sci-Tech R&D,2010,32(2):198-199. [9] 杨晓红,陈丽琼,刘婉秋.X射线荧光光谱法在环境监测中的发展与应用[J].理化检验(化学分册),2022,58(7):861-868. YANG Xiaohong,CHEN Liqiong,LIU Wanqiu.Development and application of X-ray fluorescence spectrometry in environmental monitoring[J].Physical Testing and Chemical Analysis(Part B:Chemical Analysis),2022,58(7):861-868. [10] 李新蕾,邹伟光,莫永兴,等.无损检测技术对比研究[J].工业技术创新,2018,5(2):102-105. LI Xinlei,ZOU Weiguang,MO Yongxing,et al.Comparative research on nondestructive testing technologies[J].Industrial Technology Innovation,2018,5(2):102-105. [11] 于筱然.浅析各种无损检测技术的优缺点[J].电子测试,2019(19):86-88. YU Xiaoran.The advantages and disadvantages of nondestructive testing techniques[J].Electronic Test,2019(19):86-88. [12] 葛祥凯,张悦,杨昊,等.磁粉检测技术应用及发展[J].无损探伤,2022,46(2):18-22. GE Xiangkai,ZHANG Yue,YANG Hao,et al.Application and development of magnetic particle testing technology[J].Nondestructive Testing Technology,2022,46(2):18-22. [13] 陈申乾,黄松岭,赵伟,等.燃煤锅炉热力管道缺陷检测技术[J].无损检测,2017,39(1):42-48. CHEN Shenqian,HUANG Songling,ZHAO Wei,et al.Defect detection technology of thermal pipeline in coal fired boiler[J].Nondestructive Testing,2017,39(1):42-48. [14] 廉纪祥,沈跃.管道远场涡流检测技术的进展[J].油气储运,2004,23(7):20-22. LIAN Jixiang,SHEN Yue.Transportation process[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2004,23(7):20-22. [15] Wang Z,Yuan T-B,Hou Z-Y,et al. Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy in China[J].Frontiers of Physics,2014,9(4):419-438. [16] Ikeda Y,Ofosu J A,Wakaida I.Development of microwave-enhanced fibre-coupled laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy for nuclear fuel debris screening at Fukushima[J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B Atomic Spectroscopy,2020,171:105933. [17] Wu J,Yu H,Qiu Y,et al.Plasma characteristics and element analysis of steels from a nuclear power plant based on fiber-optic laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Journal of Physics D-Applied Physics,2019,52:1. [18] Saeki M,Iwanade A,Ito C,et al.Development of a fiber-coupled laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy instrument for analysis of underwater debris in a nuclear reactor core[J].Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology,2014,51(7-8):930-938. [19] Wang Z,Deguchi Y,Katsumori S,et al.Lasers and optics interface improved measurement characteristics of elemental compositions using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Spectroscopy,2016,31(1):22-35. [20] Hu Z-Y,Zhang L,Yin W-B,et al.Application of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy to coal-fired power plants and soil contaminants on-line monitoring[J].Journal of Atmospheric and Environmental Optics,2013,8(1):26-35. [21] Balakrishnan S,Reddy V M,Mehta A,et al.Suitability of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy in screening potential additives to mitigate fouling deposits[J].Applied Physics a-Materials Science & Processing,2016,122:4. [22] Guo Q-J,Yu H-B,Xin Y,et al.Experimental study on high alloy steel sample by laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis,2010,30(3):783-787. [23] Zhao S,Zhang L,Hou J,et al.Accurate quantitative CF-LIBS analysis of both major and minor elements in alloys via iterative correction of plasma temperature and spectral intensity[J].Plasma Science & Technology,2018,3:20. [24] Hudson S W,Craparo J,De Saro R,et al.Applications of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) in molten metal processing[J].Metallurgical and Materials Transactions B (Process Metallurgy and Materials Processing Science),2017,48(5):2731-2742. [25] Khajehzadeh N,Haavisto O,Koresaar L.On-stream and quantitative mineral identification of tailing slurries using LIBS technique[J].Minerals Engineering,2016,98:101-109. [26] Kim D,Yang J-H,Choi S,et al.Analytical methods to distinguish the positive and negative spectra of mineral and environmental elements using deep ablation laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy(LIBS)[J].Applied Spectroscopy,2018,72(6):896-907. [27] Harmon R S,Shughrue K M,Remus J J,et al.Can the provenance of the conflict minerals columbite and tantalite be ascertained by laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy?[J].Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry,2011,400(10):3377-3382. [28] Takahashi T,Thornton B.Quantitative methods for compensation of matrix effects and self-absorption in laser induced breakdown spectroscopy signals of solids[J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B Atomic Spectroscopy,2017,138:31-42. [29] Rauschenbach I,Lazic V,Pavlov S G,et al.Laser induced breakdown spectroscopy on soils and rocks:Influence of the sample temperature, moisture and roughness[J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B Atomic Spectroscopy,2008,63(10):1205-1215. [30] Cabalin L M,Laserna J J.Experimental determination of laser induced breakdown thresholds of metals under nanosecond Q-switched laser operation[J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B Atomic Spectroscopy,1998,53(5):723-730. [31] 谢承利,陆继东,李捷,等.激光诱导煤粉等离子体的特性研究[J].工程热物理学报,2007(S2):133-136. XIE Chengli,LU Jidong,LI Jie,et al.Study of the property of laser-induced plasma of pulverized coal[J].Journal of Engineering Thermophysics,2007(S2):133-136. [32] 李军,陆继东,姚顺春,等.不同物理形态复合肥的激光诱导击穿光谱特性分析[J].光谱学与光谱分析,2012,32(4):881-885. LI Jun,LU Jidong,YAO Shunchun,et al.The study on the laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy properties of compound fertilizer with different physical forms[J].Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis,2012,32(4):881-885. [33] Zhu C-G,Qi H-X,Zhang J,et al.Matrix correction method used for quantitative analysis of laser induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Journal of Infrared and Millimeter Waves,2010,29(4):283-287. [34] 杨友良,王新颖.LIBS定量分析中降低基体效应的方法[J].河北联合大学学报(自然科学版),2015,37 (2):76-79. YANG Youliang,WANG Xinying.Quantitative analysis of LIBS reduces matrix effect methods[J].Journal of Hebei United University,2015,37(2):76-79. [35] Yu Z,Yao S,Jiang Y,et al.Comparison of the matrix effect in laser induced breakdown spectroscopy analysis of coal particle flow and coal pellets[J].Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry,2021,36(11):2473-2479. [36] 李俊彦,陆继东,李军,等.不同硬度受热面材料的激光诱导等离子体光谱特性分析[J].中国激光,2011,38(8):233-238. LI Junyan,LU Jidong,LI Jun,et al.Laser-induced plasma spectra of heating surface materials with different hardness[J].Chinese Journal of Lasers,2011,38(8):233-238. [37] Tsuyuki K,Miura S,Idris N,et al.Measurement of concrete strength using the emission intensity ratio between Ca(II) 396.8 nm and Ca(I) 422.6 nm in a Nd:YAG laser-induced plasma[J].Applied Spectroscopy,2006,60(1):61-64. [38] Abdel-Salam Z,Abdelhamid M,Khalil S M,et al.LIBS new application:Determination of metallic alloys surface hardness[C]//7th International Conference on Laser Applications,2009:49. [39] 李祥友,刘可,周冉,等.激光诱导击穿光谱技术及应用综述[J].中国激光,2022,49(12):152-183. LI Xiangyou,LIU Ke,ZHOU Ran,et al.Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy and its application[J].Chinese Journal of Lasers,2022,49(12):152-183. [40] Yang J,Kong L,Lian G,et al.Surface hardness determination of 3D printed parts using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Applied Optics,2021,60(3):499-504. [41] Ramezanian Z,Darbani S M R,Majd A E.Effect of self-absorption correction on surface hardness estimation of Fe-Cr-Ni alloys via LIBS[J].Applied Optics,2017,56(24):6917-6922. [42] Elfaham M M,Okil M,Mostafa A M.Limit of detection and hardness evaluation of some steel alloys utilizing optical emission spectroscopic techniques[J].Optics and Laser Technology, 2018,108:634-641. [43] Elfaham M M,Elthalabawy W M,Elzahed O,et al.Mechanical hardness estimation of heat-treated DIN50Cr3 spring steel utilizing laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) inverse calibration[J].Applied Physics a-Materials Science & Processing,2020(3):126. [44] Jia H-Y,Guo G-Q,Zhao F-Q,et al.Investigation on hardness of D2 steel based on laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis,2020,40(12):3895-3900. [45] 李军.激光诱导击穿光谱应用于电站锅炉受热面组织结构和性能诊断的研究[D].广州:华南理工大学,2016. [46] Huang J,Dong M,Lu S,et al.Estimation of the mechanical properties of steel via LIBS combined with canonical correlation analysis (CCA) and support vector regression (SVR)[J].Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry,2018,33(5):720-729. [47] Labutin T A,Popov A M,Lednev V N,et al.Correlation between properties of a solid sample and laser-induced plasma parameters[J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B Atomic Spectroscopy,2009,64(10):938-949. [48] Aberkane S M,Bendib A,Yahiaoui K,et al.Correlation between Fe-V-C alloys surface hardness and plasma temperature via LIBS technique[J].Applied Surface Science,2014,301:225-229. [49] Aberkane S M,Bendib A,Yahiaoui K,et al.Effect of laser wavelength on the correlation between plasma temperature and surface hardness of Fe-V-C metallic alloys[J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B Atomic Spectroscopy,2015,113:147-151. [50] Galmed A H,Steenkamp C,Ahmed I,et al.Using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy to monitor the surface hardness of titanium samples bombarded by carbon ions[J].Applied Physics B(Lasers and Optics),2018(12):124. [51] Galmed A H,Steenkamp C M,Ahmed I,et al.Matrix effect impact on measuring hardness of metals bombarded by accelerated ions using laser induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Journal of Laser Applications,2020(1):32. [52] Sattar H,Ran H,Ding W,et al.An approach of stand-off measuring hardness of tungsten heavy alloys using LIBS[J].Applied Physics B(Lasers and Optics),2020(1):126. [53] Sattar H,Shi J,Ran H,et al.Impact of microstructural properties on hardness of tungsten heavy alloy evaluated by stand-off LIBS after PSI plasma irradiation[J].Journal of Nuclear Materials,2020,540:15389. [54] Xin Y,Sun L-X,Yang Z-J,et al.In-situ analysis of solid steel samples with remote double-pulse laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy system[J].Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis,2016,36(7):2255-2259. [55] Yao S,Lu J,Chen K,et al.Study of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy to discriminate pearlitic/ferritic from martensitic phases[J].Applied Surface Science,2011(7):3103-3110. [56] Yao S,Dong M,Lu J,et al.Correlation between grade of pearlite spheroidization and laser induced spectra[J].Laser Physics,2013(12):23. [57] 国家能源局,中国电力行业. DL/T 884—2019火电厂金相检验与评定技术导则[S].北京:中国电力出版社,2019. [58] Li J,Lu J,Dai Y,et al.Correlation between aging grade of T91 steel and spectral characteristics of the laser-induced plasma[J].Applied Surface Science,2015,346:302-310. [59] Lu S,Dong M,Huang J,et al.Estimation of the aging grade of T91 steel by laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy coupled with support vector machines[J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B Atomic Spectroscopy,2018,140:35-43. [60] Huang J,Dong M,Lu S,et al.A hybrid model combining wavelet transform and recursive feature elimination for running state evaluation of heat-resistant steel using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Ana-lyst,2019,144(12):3736-3745. [61] Zhang Y,Dong M,Cai J,et al.Study on the evaluation of the aging grade for industrial heat-resistant steel by laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry,2022,37(1):139-147. [62] Lu S,Shen S,Huang J,et al.Feature selection of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy data for steel aging estimation[J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B Atomic Spectroscopy,2018,150:49-58. [63] 余移山,陆继东,董美蓉,等. T91金属管道表面特性对LIBS测量的影响[J].应用科技,2020,47(4):82-87. YU Yishan,LU Jidong,DONG Meirong,et al.Study on the influence of surface characteristics of T91 metal pipeline on laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy measurement[J].Applied Science and Technology,2020,47(4):82-87. [64] Lu S,Dong M,Chen Q,et al.Temporal-spatial resolved laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy of T91 steel of different aging grades[J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B Atomic Spectroscopy,2019,151:1-11. [65] 张勇升,董美蓉,蔡俊斌,等.基于便携式激光诱导击穿光谱技术的耐热钢老化等级评估[J].冶金分析,2020,40(12):86-93. ZHANG Yongsheng,DONG Meirong,CAI Junbin,et al.Estimation of the aging grade of heat-resistant steel based on portable laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Metallurgical Analysis,2020,40(12):86-93. [66] Cai J,Dong M,Zhang Y,et al.Estimating the aging grade of heat-resistant steel by using portable laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy[J].Atomic Spectroscopy,2021,42(2):43-50.
